Moral policing of Indian Women
Posted in From the Director's Desk on January 10th, 2012 by Centre for Social Research – Be the first to commentBy Dr. Ranjana Kumari, Director of Centre for Social Research.
Sexual violence is a widespread problem in India that affects women from all classes, castes and socio-economic groups. In 2009 a total of 21,397 rape incidents were reported across the country and many more remain un-reported. Statistics show that 44 percent of sexual assault victims are under the age of 18 and approximately two-thirds of assaults are committed by someone known to the survivor. Furthermore, more than 70 percent of women with developmental disabilities experience sexual assault. In the nation’s capital, Delhi, there has been an increase in the number of reported rape cases from 459 in 2009 to 489 in 2011. The increase in the number of reported cases of rape has led to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) identifying rape as the fastest growing crime in India.
Discussions throughout India, and across the world, about the causes of rape as well as the best ways to prevent rape and to prosecute rapists are largely underpinned by patriarchal assumptions of gender and sexually and are extremely problematic.
There is a tendency within India society, both males and females, to blame the victims of rape or sexual assault. The rape incident is often sexualised and women are accused of behaving inappropriately and inciting the rapists’ behavior. In some cases women are accused of dressing provocatively, whilst in others of travelling alone too late at night. This reinforces the idea that women must behave in a certain manner and must be controlled by men. Their failure to conform to gendered expectations is used as a justification for the rape and restores the appearance of safety and security within the community.
The focus on sexuality and men’s sexual desires tends to reinforce patriarchal gender stereotypes and in some ways justifies the actions of rapists who are considered to be more sexual than women and are therefore less able to control their sexual desires. However, it is evident that rape, as with other forms of gender based violence, is a manifestation of the patriarchal need to control and subjugate women. Therefore, rape represents an attempt by the rapist to exert power over the rape victim. Yet it is also reflects a broader need to reinforce patriarchal social structures that dictate gendered social structures and divisions and perpetuate gender-based discrimination and inequality.
The attention to women’s dress and character is largely used to shift the focus away from the perpetrator’s actions. Existing efforts to combat sexual violence are largely focused on lecturing women about what they should be doing to avoid rape, instead of talking to men about the fact they do not have the right to women’s bodies without explicit consent. By focusing on the behavior of women, the male perpetrators of violence are inadvertently condoned. Women should not be held responsible for the behavior of perpetrators of sexual violence. Therefore, there is a need to focus on holding perpetrators accountable and educating both men and women of women’s rights rather than to blame and vindicate victims of sexual violence.